Products are selected by our editors, we may earn commission from links on this page.
McDonald’s has announced a significant change to its payment policy, implementing a rounding system for cash transactions due to a nationwide penny shortage. The adjustment follows President Trump’s executive order earlier this year to halt penny production, citing the coin’s production cost exceeding its face value. While the policy aims to address practical challenges, it has sparked mixed reactions from customers who question the fairness and necessity of the change. But what exactly prompted Trump to make this controversial decision in the first place?
Trump Orders End to Penny Production
President Donald Trump instructed the U.S. Treasury to stop producing pennies shortly after taking office, calling the practice wasteful. The penny costs over two cents to manufacture, making it economically inefficient. The U.S. Mint placed its final order for penny blanks in May, and production will cease once supplies are depleted. The Treasury estimates this decision will save $56 million annually in material costs, marking a significant shift in American currency circulation. With pennies disappearing from registers nationwide, McDonald’s had to develop a practical solution for cash transactions.
How McDonald’s Rounding System Works
McDonald’s new policy rounds cash transactions to the nearest five cents when exact change isn’t available. Orders ending in 1 or 2 cents round down to 0, while 3 or 4 cents round up to 5. Similarly, 6 or 7 cents round down to 5, and 8 or 9 cents round up to 10 cents. Menu prices remain unchanged, but the final total is adjusted. However, not all customers will experience this change the same way.
Card Payments Remain Unaffected
The rounding policy exclusively impacts cash transactions, leaving credit card, debit card, and mobile app payments unchanged. These cashless options continue to charge exact amounts down to the penny. McDonald’s noted that digital and card payments represent the majority of transactions in the United States, meaning most customers won’t experience any difference. The company encourages customers to use exact change or cashless methods, which also provide access to various national and local promotional deals.
Customer Reactions
McDonald’s customers expressed mixed feelings about the policy on social media. Some voiced concerns about potential exploitation, suggesting companies might manipulate prices to consistently round upward and pocket extra cents. Another frustrated customer said: “Just change the d— prices. You say the prices stay unchanged, but then charge more or less at the end of the transaction.” The inconsistency between stated prices and actual charges frustrated several customers, despite the company’s assurances that rounding would balance out fairly over time.
Support for Retiring the Penny
Not all reactions were negative—many customers supported eliminating the penny entirely. They pointed out that other countries successfully operate without low-denomination coins, and the United States historically retired its half-cent coin when it held more purchasing power than today’s dime. Some argued for extending elimination to nickels as well, citing inflation’s erosion of these coins’ practical value. These customers view McDonald’s policy as a reasonable adaptation to an overdue currency modernization.
Impact on Retailers Nationwide
McDonald’s isn’t alone in facing penny shortage challenges. Businesses across the country are implementing various strategies to adapt. Sheetz, a convenience store chain, launched a promotion offering free sodas to customers who brought in pennies to help replenish their supply. However, industry experts note the abrupt change without comprehensive federal guidance creates operational stress for retailers navigating this transition independently, forcing each business to develop its own solution.
Industry Expert Concerns
While many experts have long advocated for penny elimination, they criticize the execution of Trump’s decision. Jeff Lenard from the National Association of Convenience Stores stated his organization has supported abolishing the penny for three decades, but expressed frustration with the uncoordinated approach. The lack of federal government guidance forces retailers to improvise rounding policies and customer communication strategies, creating inconsistency across businesses and potential confusion for consumers navigating different systems at various establishments.
Long-Term Solutions and Future Outlook
McDonald’s confirms it’s developing long-term solutions to simplify transactions while maintaining fairness for customers. The company references international precedents where similar currency changes led businesses to adopt comparable rounding practices successfully. As the penny shortage intensifies, McDonald’s continues working with federal authorities to obtain clearer guidance. The fast-food chain emphasizes its commitment to keeping the process straightforward for customers while adapting to this significant change in American currency circulation.
Navigating America’s Cashless Transition
McDonald’s penny policy represents a broader shift in American commerce as the nation adapts to Trump’s penny elimination decision. While the rounding system has sparked customer debate about fairness and pricing transparency, it reflects challenges facing all retailers nationwide. As cashless payments dominate transactions and pennies disappear from circulation, businesses and consumers alike must adjust to new payment norms. The controversy highlights the complexities of currency changes and the importance of clear communication during major economic transitions.