Products are selected by our editors, we may earn commission from links on this page.
Tiffany and Robert Maillet just wanted a working van. Instead, they say a Nissan dealership’s general manager turned a single bad review into an attack on their small business, one review at a time.
This article was created with the assistance of AI and reviewed by our editorial team for accuracy and clarity.
The Transmission Failed Almost Immediately, the Couple Says
The Maillets bought a van from Nissan of Cape Coral in Florida, expecting a reliable vehicle for personal use. According to the couple, problems surfaced almost right away, including what they describe as a faulty transmission. They say getting the dealership to actually help them fix it proved far harder than buying the van in the first place.
Tiffany Posted a Detailed Google Review of Her Experience
Frustrated by the response from the dealership, Tiffany Maillet did what countless car buyers do when a purchase goes wrong. She left a one-star Google review, laying out exactly what happened with the van and the service she received afterward. It seemed like the end of the story. For the dealership’s general manager, it was only the start.
GM Blake Varnadoe Allegedly Targeted the Couple’s Upholstery Business
Tiffany alleges General Manager Blake Varnadoe responded to her review by posting negative reviews of RT Upholstery, the couple’s business, and encouraging his friends to pile on. The retaliation, she says, moved past a car complaint and into an attempt to damage the livelihood she and Robert had built from nothing.
“They’re Coming After Our Livelihood,” Tiffany Said in a Viral Video
Tiffany documented the alleged retaliation in a TikTok video that would eventually rack up roughly 1.4 million views before it was removed. “Not only does he come attacking my business, he’s sending his friends to attack my business as well,” she said. “They’re coming after our livelihood.” The internet had questions for Varnadoe.
Robert Maillet Asked What Would Have Happened Without the Video
Robert Maillet later posed a pointed question to viewers: what if Tiffany hadn’t posted the video, or hadn’t had a large following to amplify it? He argued that without that reach, Varnadoe could have recruited more friends and employees to keep hitting their business, leaving the couple with no way to defend themselves at all.
Krause Auto Group Calls the Retaliation “Inappropriate”
Nissan of Cape Coral’s parent company, Krause Auto Group, issued a formal statement acknowledging what it called an inappropriate online response by a member of dealership management. The company said it had personally contacted the Maillets to apologize and was taking corrective action, though it never specified what discipline, if any, Varnadoe actually faced.
Varnadoe Apologizes on Facebook, Cites Time Away for Training
Varnadoe posted his own apology to the dealership’s Facebook page. “I accept responsibility for the embarrassment and disruption my actions caused,” he wrote. He said he would use time away from the dealership to complete professional conduct training and reflect on his decisions, promising the behavior would never happen again.
Nissan of Cape Coral’s Own Ratings Got Flooded With Backlash
Once Tiffany’s video spread, Nissan of Cape Coral found itself facing the exact tactic Varnadoe allegedly used against RT Upholstery. Its Google listing, Yelp page, and social media accounts filled with negative comments from viewers siding with the couple. The Maillets, notably, asked people to stop, urging viewers not to retaliate against the dealership’s other employees.
A Small Business Fought Back, and the Internet Evened the Score
The Maillets never asked for a viral moment. They asked for a working van and a fair hearing. What they got instead was a public reckoning that neither the dealership nor its general manager could control once it started. Two apologies later, the lesson stands clear: retaliation against a customer rarely stays contained to just one customer.