Products are selected by our editors, we may earn commission from links on this page.
Mascara can lift your whole face, but it can also slip under your eyes. One minute you’re feeling polished, and the next you’re dealing with smudges that weren’t invited. It happens fast and always at the worst time.
Lunch break mirror checks don’t lie. If your lashes start strong but end up smearing by noon, you’re not alone. Skip the heavy concealer cover-up. Try these simple fixes to keep your mascara where it belongs all day.
Why Does Mascara Smudge?
So here’s what’s really going on. Your eyelids might be too hydrated. Sounds strange, but oily lids break down mascara fast. The skin around your eyes is thinner, so it shows signs of dryness earlier. That’s why your body keeps it extra moisturized.
Mascara also smudges when it doesn’t stick to your lashes properly. Some formulas just don’t hang on. But you don’t have to rely on waterproof to fix it. There are other ways to stop the smudge.
Tip 1: Cleanse Your Face
Mascara sticks better when your skin’s clean. So always start with a fresh face. Use a gentle cleanser that removes everything like makeup, oil, and leftover skincare, especially around your lashes and lids.
Don’t forget your lash line. It collects way more buildup than you think. A clean base helps mascara hold on longer and keeps it from sliding off midday. You can also try using coconut oil or a lash-safe balm for a little extra care while cleansing.
Tip 2: Apply a Primer
Primer gives your lashes a better grip. It creates a smooth surface that helps mascara stay where it should. A good primer also blocks oil from reaching your lashes too fast, which helps stop smudging before it starts.
You can use a regular eyeshadow primer if your lids get oily during the day. If your skin feels dry, go for a fast-absorbing beauty oil. Let it sink in fully. That quick prep step can make a big difference.
Tip 3: Use a Tri-Locking Mascara
A tri-locking mascara provides a stay-put finish without being waterproof. It holds onto your lashes in layers, so it resists smudging without feeling stiff or flaky.
Look for a formula that uses clean ingredients and skips the heavy stuff like silicones. Some even include peptides to support your lashes while you wear them. You’ll get bold color that lasts through heat, humidity, and whatever else the day throws at you.
Tip 4: Lightly Dust Under the Eyes
Go easy under the eyes. A thick layer of concealer and powder won’t stop smudging. It just makes everything look heavy and cakey.
Instead, try a light dusting of translucent powder. It helps absorb extra oil without drying out your skin or settling into fine lines. A gentle sweep with a small brush is sufficient. You’ll still look fresh, but your mascara won’t have anything slick to slide onto.
Tip 5: Wipe Your Undereyes Occasionally
Mascara isn’t supposed to cling for dear life. Smudges can still show up, even with a long-wear formula, so a little maintenance goes a long way.
Keep a few blotting papers or a clean tissue on hand and gently dab under your eyes when needed. That quick swipe helps remove oil and prevents any sneaky mascara from settling in. You can also blot near the brow bone if your lids tend to be oily.
Tip 6: Avoid Oil
Oil and mascara don’t mix well. Even if your skin isn’t super oily, anything creamy around your eyes can break down your mascara fast. That includes rich eye creams, balms, or oil-based skincare. Save those for nighttime.
During the day, opt for lightweight products that absorb quickly and stay in place. Heat and sweat can also sneak in and make things worse, so stick to oil-free if you want your mascara actually to stay where you put it.
Tip 7: Find your Formula
Not every mascara works the same for everyone, so it’s helpful to determine what your lashes actually like. Some people swear by waterproof, but you can also layer your usual mascara with a waterproof topcoat.
A clear brow gel works too—just swipe it on after to help lock everything in. If you’re over flakes and smudges, try a tubing mascara. Those wrap around each lash and stay put until you rinse with warm water.
Tip 8: Grab a Cotton Swab
Mascara smudges show up even when you’re doing everything right. If you get a mark on your lid or under your eye, just wait a minute. Let it dry completely before touching it. Once it’s dry, gently flick it away using a cotton swab. A dry spoolie works too if that’s what you have nearby. It takes two seconds and saves you from smearing it even more.
Should I Cover with Concealer?
It’s tempting just to dab some concealer over a smudge and move on. But that usually makes things worse. You’ll need more product than usual to cover the dark spot, and that extra layer can become oily quickly.
Then your mascara keeps transferring, and you keep adding more concealer. It turns into a messy loop. You’ll end up with creased makeup, and the smudge will still peek through. It’s better to clean it up instead.
Keep Your Lashes Clean and Locked In
Mascara doesn’t need to smudge halfway through the day. Stick with light layers, blot when needed, and pick a formula that stays put. Clean tools and simple touch-ups help too.
If you keep things light and build smart, your lashes won’t melt off your face by lunch. Try a few of these swaps in your routine and see which ones stick. It really comes down to being a little more mindful when applying.