Products are selected by our editors, we may earn commission from links on this page.

Black Friday 2026 is approaching, and millions of Americans are preparing to hunt for discounts on everything from holiday gifts and electronics to clothing and household essentials. However, not every retailer offers the same level of savings, and some familiar shopping destinations may provide much smaller discounts than customers expect. A WalletHub analysis of more than 3,100 Black Friday deals from 13 major retailers in 2025 identified eight stores with particularly strong advertised markdowns, offering shoppers a useful starting point as they compare this year’s holiday promotions.
JCPenney: The Store With the Biggest Average Discounts

JCPenney claimed the top position in WalletHub’s latest available Black Friday discount analysis, offering an impressive average advertised discount of 74.08% across the products examined in 2025. The department store stood out for its jewelry, clothing, and appliance promotions, with jewelry discounts averaging 74.51% and appliance markdowns reaching approximately 57.63%. For shoppers planning to purchase holiday gifts or replace household appliances in 2026, JCPenney could be worth checking first, although actual savings will depend on the specific deals offered this year.
Belk: A Surprising Second Place for Holiday Savings

Belk secured second place in WalletHub’s ranking with an average advertised discount of 72.42%, putting it just behind JCPenney and well ahead of several larger national retailers. The department store performed particularly well in jewelry, where the average advertised discount reached 77.66%, while appliances and apparel also offered substantial markdowns during the analyzed sale. Although Belk operates physical stores in a limited number of states, its online shopping options make it possible for customers across the country to compare holiday offers without visiting a nearby location.
Kohl’s: A Strong Choice for Clothing and Home Essentials

Kohl’s ranked third in WalletHub’s analysis, with an average advertised Black Friday discount of 45.39%, making it another retailer worth considering for holiday shopping. Its strongest category was apparel and accessories, with markdowns averaging 53.54%, while appliances followed with average discounts of approximately 42.40%. Shoppers looking for winter clothing, family gifts, or smaller household appliances may find worthwhile promotions at Kohl’s, particularly when comparing eligible store rewards and discounts with prices offered elsewhere.
Macy’s: Holiday Shoppers Could Find Major Jewelry Savings

Macy’s placed fourth in the ranking with an average advertised discount of 44.46%, making it one of the stronger department store options in WalletHub’s 2025 comparison. The retailer offered particularly notable savings on jewelry, where advertised markdowns averaged 57.05%, while furniture discounts reached approximately 40.02% and apparel discounts averaged 37.51%. For shoppers considering jewelry, home furnishings, or clothing as holiday gifts, Macy’s could offer appealing opportunities, although comparing individual products remains important because the size of a discount does not always guarantee the lowest final price.
Home Depot: A Place to Check for Home Improvement Deals

Home Depot ranked fifth among the retailers examined, posting an average advertised discount of 35.63% during the 2025 Black Friday shopping period. The home improvement retailer performed especially well in furniture and appliances, with average markdowns of 41.02% and 37.44%, respectively, making it a potential destination for shoppers planning household upgrades. Whether someone is searching for a practical holiday gift or preparing for a home improvement project, comparing Home Depot’s current promotions with competitors could help determine whether buying during Black Friday offers meaningful savings.
BJ’s Wholesale Club: Members Could Find Worthwhile Discounts

BJ’s Wholesale Club secured sixth place in WalletHub’s ranking, with an average advertised discount of 31.26% across its analyzed Black Friday offers. Consumer electronics stood out with average discounts of 35.49%, while furniture followed at 33.33%, suggesting that members could find opportunities to save on larger holiday purchases. Because BJ’s operates as a membership-based retailer, shoppers should consider whether the available discounts justify membership costs and compare final prices with those offered by stores that do not require a paid membership.
Amazon: Online Convenience Comes With Competitive Discounts

Amazon ranked seventh in WalletHub’s analysis, with an average advertised discount of 29.63%, demonstrating that its enormous product selection does not necessarily translate into the largest overall markdowns. The online retailer performed particularly well in computers and phones, where advertised discounts averaged 38.91%, while consumer electronics and appliances also offered opportunities for savings. For shoppers who prefer ordering gifts from home, Amazon’s convenience and broad selection remain attractive, but checking price histories and comparing competing retailers can help prevent purchases that only appear to be heavily discounted.
Target: A Familiar Favorite for Holiday Gifts and Toys

Target rounded out WalletHub’s top eight retailers, offering an average advertised Black Friday discount of 29.36% across the products included in the 2025 study. Its strongest categories included toys, with average discounts of 34.97%, and appliances, which averaged 34.33%, making the retailer particularly relevant for families shopping for children and household gifts. Although Target ranked below several department stores for overall advertised discounts, its combination of toys, seasonal decorations, and everyday essentials could make it a convenient shopping destination for households planning to complete multiple purchases in one trip.
Comparing Prices Could Be the Best Black Friday Strategy

WalletHub’s findings show that the biggest advertised Black Friday discounts do not always come from the retailers shoppers might immediately expect, with department stores such as JCPenney and Belk outperforming several major online and big-box competitors in the 2025 analysis. However, these rankings are based on previous promotional advertisements and do not guarantee that the same stores will offer identical discounts during Black Friday 2026, which falls on November 27. Before making a purchase, shoppers should compare current prices, review return policies, and focus on items they already planned to buy, helping ensure that holiday discounts translate into genuine savings rather than unnecessary spending.

