Products are selected by our editors, we may earn commission from links on this page.
FBI Director Kash Patel is facing renewed scrutiny after government emails obtained by The Associated Press revealed he participated in what officials described as a “VIP snorkel” around the USS Arizona Memorial during an official visit to Hawaii last summer.
According to the reports, Patel’s trip initially appeared routine. The FBI publicly highlighted his walking tour of the Honolulu field office and meetings with local law enforcement while emphasizing he was not vacationing in Hawaii. But the newly disclosed emails revealed Patel later returned to the islands for an additional two days and joined a military-coordinated snorkeling excursion at Pearl Harbor.
The USS Arizona Memorial sits above the remains of the battleship sunk during Japan’s 1941 attack on Pearl Harbor. More than 900 sailors and Marines remain entombed inside the wreckage, making the site both a national memorial and military cemetery. Snorkeling and diving around the Arizona are generally prohibited except for preservation work, military operations, and limited authorized access.
A Sacred Site at the Center of Debate
The revelation quickly triggered debate over whether such an excursion was appropriate at one of the nation’s most solemn historical sites. Critics argued the issue was not simply about access, but about optics and judgment surrounding a location widely viewed as sacred ground.
Marine veteran Hack Albertson, who participates in authorized annual dives to monitor the wreck’s condition, criticized recreational-style visits to the memorial, telling The Associated Press it was “like having a bachelor party at a church.” He argued the USS Arizona should be treated with “the solemnity it deserves,” echoing concerns from veterans and historians who view the site primarily as a place of remembrance and military sacrifice.
Others, however, took a more measured view. Family members connected to Pearl Harbor survivors told reporters they were not necessarily offended by carefully managed official excursions. Deidre Kelley, president of the Sons and Daughters of Pearl Harbor Survivors, told The Associated Press she had not heard widespread objections to the rare, tightly controlled excursions, though she noted some family members have expressed interest in being granted similar access themselves.
Military officials noted that dignitaries have occasionally been granted similar access dating back to at least the Obama administration. According to former officials familiar with the practice, participants have included admirals and Cabinet-level officials involved with overseeing military and memorial operations. The Navy described Patel’s outing as “not an anomaly,” though officials declined to provide details on how often such trips occur.
Questions Grow Around Patel’s Travel and Leadership
The snorkeling controversy arrives amid broader criticism surrounding Patel’s leadership and use of government resources during his tenure as FBI director. Over the past year, questions have repeatedly surfaced about his travel schedule, personal appearances, and blending of official business with high-profile public events.
Earlier this year, Patel faced scrutiny after appearing in celebratory locker room videos with the U.S. men’s hockey team following its Olympic gold medal win in Milan. Critics questioned whether the trip served a legitimate law enforcement purpose or crossed into personal publicity. Patel defended the visit, saying it was connected to an international cybercrime investigation involving Italian authorities.
Separate allegations involving government aircraft usage, excessive drinking, and erratic management behavior have also followed Patel in recent months. Patel has strongly denied those accusations, calling reports about his conduct “unequivocally, categorically false.” The FBI has meanwhile pointed to declining crime rates and major arrests under his leadership as evidence that agency priorities remain intact.
Still, the Pearl Harbor revelations have added momentum to ongoing concerns from former Justice Department officials and government watchdogs. Stacey Young, founder of Justice Connection, said the episode fit what she described as a larger pattern of “unseemly distractions” overshadowing the bureau’s mission.
The USS Arizona’s Historical Weight Shapes the Reaction
Part of the intensity surrounding the story stems from the symbolism of the USS Arizona itself. The battleship has become one of America’s most recognized World War II memorials since the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor killed more than 1,100 crew members aboard the ship alone.
The memorial’s white structure spans above the submerged wreckage without touching it directly. Visitors typically approach the site quietly, aware they are standing above the remains of service members who never escaped the explosion and fire that consumed the ship. Oil droplets that continue to rise from the wreck are often referred to as the “black tears of the Arizona.”
Because of that history, even authorized access to the waters surrounding the memorial carries deep emotional and symbolic significance. Participants in Patel’s outing were reportedly instructed not to touch the wreck and were briefed on the site’s historic importance before entering the water.
The FBI has declined to answer detailed questions about Patel’s snorkeling session or what he did during the additional days spent in Hawaii. Flight tracking data cited in reports showed the FBI’s Gulfstream aircraft remained on the island for two nights before continuing on to Las Vegas. As scrutiny continues, the controversy has become less about whether the excursion was technically permitted and more about whether public officials should engage in such activities at one of the nation’s most revered military memorials.